There is a push in Congress to reauthorize the nation’s main anti-trafficking law before the end of the year. Unfortunately, H.R. 1144 does not fix a longstanding provision that gives smugglers a reason to bring unaccompanied minors to the border.
NumbersUSA opposes reauthorizing the law until that provision is fixed.
The loophole that encourages child smuggling
The Trafficking Victims Protection Act dates to 2000, and Congress has renewed it several times. The 2008 renewal, the Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act (TVPRA), added a section on “unaccompanied alien children.” That is the legal term for minors who are in the country illegally and have no parent or legal guardian here to care for them.
Section 235 of the 2008 law treats these children differently depending on where they come from:
- A child from Mexico or Canada can be screened and returned home quickly, as long as he has not been trafficked and has no fear of going back.
- A child from any other country must be transferred to the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) within 72 hours. HHS then places the child with an adult “sponsor” in the United States while the child’s immigration case is decided, which can take years.
In other words, a child from Guatemala or Honduras who makes it across the border is all but certain to stay. Smugglers exploit that loophole.
From 8,000 to 149,000
The Congressional Research Service has tracked Border Patrol apprehensions of unaccompanied children at the southwest border:
- 8,041 in fiscal year 2008, before the provision became law.
- 68,541 in fiscal year 2014, a record at the time.
- 30,557 in fiscal year 2020.
- 149,093 in fiscal year 2022, the highest on record.
The record came under President Biden. Customs and Border Protection’s nationwide data, which also count children who arrive at ports of entry, show about 550,000 unaccompanied children encountered between February 2021 and January 2025. Hundreds of thousands ended up as child laborers.
Released to “sponsors” with little follow-up
The government could not keep up with the children it released.
The HHS inspector general reviewed cases from early 2021 and found that 16 percent of the files had no record that one or more required sponsor safety checks were ever done.
The Department of Homeland Security’s inspector general reported in August 2024 that more than 32,000 unaccompanied children had failed to appear for their immigration court hearings over five years. As of May 2024, more than 291,000 others had never been served a notice to appear, so their immigration cases had not begun.
A law written to protect children from traffickers drew hundreds of thousands of them into the country, and the government then lost track of many of them.
Bipartisan lip service, but no action
In June 2014, President Obama wrote to congressional leaders asking for “additional authority” to return unaccompanied children from countries such as Guatemala, Honduras, and El Salvador.
Ten days earlier, then-Vice President Biden was in Guatemala City, where he warned that smugglers “routinely engage in physical and sexual abuse” of the children they carry.
Congress did not act. Seven years later, Biden was president during the largest surge of unaccompanied children on record.
Why a “secure border” is not enough
CBP counted 9,190 unaccompanied children nationwide in fiscal year 2026. In fiscal year 2022 the count was 152,880. That is a 94 percent drop.
The drop came from President Trump’s border policies. The law itself, including section 235, is the same. A future administration less focused on the border could easily allow the exploitation to resume, intentionally or not.
That is the danger in reauthorizing the TVPRA as it is. Congress would be renewing an anti-trafficking law and leaving in place the provision that puts children in the hands of smugglers. A reauthorization is the natural time to fix a law. If this one passes unchanged, the next chance could be years away.
How to fix it
NumbersUSA is asking Congress to amend the law before reauthorizing it. The changes would:
- Return responsibility for unaccompanied children from HHS to the Department of Homeland Security.
- Screen all unaccompanied children quickly and return them home safely, the way the law already treats children from Mexico and Canada.
- Repeal the special immigration benefits the 2008 law created for unaccompanied children, including taxpayer-funded legal representation.
- Make clear that families are to be detained together.
- Make clear that a minor is no longer “unaccompanied” once he has a parent or legal guardian in the United States, or once he turns 18.
- Prohibit placing children with sponsors who are in the country illegally.
- Vet every sponsor, require home visits, and require sponsors to check in with the government while a child’s case is pending.
Congress should make these changes before it reauthorizes the TVPRA.
Not Your Members? | Create Account or Log In to manually enter your address.