On Nov. 17, the Washington Sun reported that House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, the presumptive next Speaker, pledged to move the American Dream and Promise Act early in the next Congress. The bill’s sponsor, Rep. Sylvia Garcia (D-Texas), is trying to get there sooner. The Sun quoted her from a press conference last week:
“We have 217 signatures. We just need one more Republican.”
Garcia was talking about a discharge petition. That is a House procedure that lets a majority of Members force a floor vote on a bill without a committee’s approval. Her petition needs 218 signatures. In a Facebook post a few days earlier, she praised Jeffries’s remarks and summed up the plan:
“It will be prioritized next Congress, but why wait?”
Jeffries backs the petition. On Nov. 9, he told reporters he hoped to get the last signature. Last week, he said, “We can begin by moving in the House, and ultimately in the Senate,” the Dream and Promise Act, in order to restore protections for people covered by two programs, DACA and Temporary Protected Status (TPS).
In other words, House Democratic leaders plan to bring amnesty to the floor. An amnesty lets people who broke immigration law stay and work here legally. The vote could happen in January. With one more signature, it could happen before this Congress adjourns.
One signature short of 218
Discharge Petition No. 25 has 217 signatures. Three of them came from Republicans, and each link below goes to that Member’s NumbersUSA grade for this Congress:
- Rep. Maria Elvira Salazar of Florida: D (30 percent)
- Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick of Pennsylvania: D+ (33 percent)
- Rep. Don Bacon of Nebraska: D+ (35 percent)
The other 214 are Democrats. Without those three Republicans, the petition would be four signatures short instead of one.
A petition does not produce a vote the day it reaches 218. Under House rules, it must first wait on the House calendar for seven legislative days. After that, any Member who signed it can call it up, and House leaders have two legislative days to schedule the vote. The petition expires when this Congress ends on Jan. 3.
Supporters are pressing for the signature now. An ACLU action alert tells supporters they need “just one more signature to force a vote before Congress breaks until 2027.” An immigration law firm’s alert calls the lame-duck session, the weeks between the election and the new Congress, “the last chance to move it forward in this Congress.”
Green cards for up to 5.4 million
H.R. 1589 would give green cards and a path to citizenship to three groups:
- “Dreamers.” People who entered the country at age 18 or younger and have been here since Jan. 1, 2021. Estimates of how many qualify run from 2.3 million to 3.9 million. Only about one in five currently holds DACA, the 2012 program that defers deportation for people brought here as minors.
- People with TPS. The program lets nationals of designated countries stay and work in the United States while conditions at home are judged unsafe. The version headed to the floor would cover about 1.45 million people.
- A smaller group covered by a similar program called Deferred Enforced Departure.
Added together, the bill would make an estimated 3.7 million to 5.4 million people eligible. Using the most recent outside estimate of the Dreamer population, the figure is about 4.1 million.
The bill would also do the following:
- Every applicant would get a work permit while the application is pending, and no one who appears eligible could be removed until a final decision.
- Some people who were deported on or after Jan. 20, 2017, could apply from abroad.
- None of the green cards would count against any annual limit. They would be added on top of current immigration.
Earlier versions of the bill passed the House in 2019 and 2021. The Senate never voted on either.
A “temporary” program made permanent
TPS is supposed to be temporary. During the Biden administration it grew from about 320,000 people to 1.3 million, according to Congressional Research Service reports.
The bill as introduced covered people who had TPS on Jan. 1, 2017. The rule the petition would bring to the floor moves that date to July 1, 2024.
- As introduced: about 390,000 people.
- Floor version: about 1.45 million people.
That one change in the date has three effects:
- It adds about 1 million people.
- It brings in six countries first designated under President Biden, including Venezuela, Ukraine, and Afghanistan.
- About 1.1 million of the people covered have since had their TPS designations terminated. The bill would reverse those terminations and replace them with green cards.
In other words, the bill would take the Biden-era expansion of a “temporary” program and write most of it into permanent law. Congress would be doubling down on Biden-era border policies.
No enforcement, no E-Verify
The bill contains no enforcement of any kind:
- No E-Verify, the system employers use to confirm that new hires are authorized to work.
- No border security or interior enforcement.
- No cut to any other immigration category to offset the new green cards.
- No limit on future TPS designations.
Employers who hired illegally would end up with a legal workforce and no penalty. The Americans they passed over would get nothing. And because the bill changes none of the conditions that produced the population it legalizes, the same thing could happen again.
The Congressional Budget Office has not scored H.R. 1589. Its 2021 estimate of the smaller predecessor bill found it would add $35.3 billion to deficits over 10 years.
What the caravans are hearing
On Nov. 8, a caravan of several hundred mostly Honduran migrants reached Tapachula, Mexico. One man told La Jornada he had heard the Democrats won the election, and “maybe they could help us cross the border and get better jobs.”
A senior Border Patrol official in Texas told the Washington Examiner what the cartels are telling migrants: “The message is already being sent. ‘The borders will be opened again.’”
Migrants weigh the risks against the rewards. A House vote to give green cards to millions of people who came or stayed illegally, with no enforcement attached, would raise the reward and invite the next border crisis. We covered the caravans in detail in “The Caravan Is Reading Washington.”
What happens next
The House is in session for a few more weeks this year. Supporters need one more Member to sign. Every Member who hasn’t signed should stay off the petition, and the three Republicans who have should take their names off. A signature can be withdrawn at any time before the petition reaches 218.
Meanwhile, the border bill the House Judiciary Committee approved in July, H.R. 9773, is still waiting for a floor vote. Congress has not written the secure border into law, but it is one signature from a vote on amnesty.
Not Your Members? | Create Account or Log In to manually enter your address.